Essential Eight checklist for a first assessment
For a first Essential Eight assessment, settle the scope and boundary, ask for Maturity Level One first, gather dated evidence for each of the eight strategies, document every exception with compensating controls, and agree the sample with the assessor. ASD's assessment guide (October 2024) expects the strategies assessed as a package. Organisations new to the framework can also read ASD's Essentials for enterprise IT.
What should be settled before the assessor arrives?
Start with the boundary. ASD's assessment guide has the assessor agree the scope with the system owner, document anything left out with a reason, and agree access to accounts, devices, documentation and staff. Decide who may approve scripts and tools on your systems, where evidence will be stored and protected, and which service providers manage parts of the system, because the assessor will want to speak to them.
Then settle the level. ASD advises implementing and assessing each level in turn, and says an owner who has not shown Level One should not be assessed against Level Two. The assessor will ask for your target. This site does not advise on which to choose. The Level Two guide covers what is added when Level Two is the target.
What is the Maturity Level One checklist by strategy?
Patch applications: automated asset discovery at least fortnightly; scans daily for online services and weekly for office suites, browsers, email clients, PDF software and security products; 48 hours for critical or exploited vulnerabilities in online services and two weeks otherwise; two weeks for the desktop applications; unsupported versions removed. Patch operating systems: daily scans of internet-facing servers and network devices, fortnightly for the rest; 48 hours or two weeks for internet-facing systems, one month for others; unsupported systems replaced.
Multi-factor authentication: required for users of online services handling sensitive data, including third-party services, and for customers of online customer services holding sensitive data. Restrict administrative privileges: privileged access validated on request, a separate privileged account with no internet, email or web access, and separate privileged and unprivileged environments. Application control: on workstations, covering user profiles and temporary folders, for the listed file types.
Restrict Microsoft Office macros: disabled for users with no demonstrated business need, blocked from the internet, antivirus scanning on, settings locked. User application hardening: Internet Explorer 11 disabled or removed, no Java or web advertisements processed by browsers, settings locked. Regular backups: kept in line with business criticality, synchronised to a common point in time, restoration tested in a disaster recovery exercise, and unprivileged accounts unable to access others' backups or change any backup.
Which evidence should be gathered for each strategy?
Gather the highest grade of evidence you can. ASD ranks a live test above a configuration view, a configuration view above a screenshot, and a screenshot above a policy. Keep dated scan outputs, the application control ruleset, a list of accounts with their expiry, the macro policy settings, hardening settings, and a backup restoration report. ASD's example test plans for Levels One, Two and Three, and its assessment report template, show the format an assessor will use.
Run ASD's verification tools yourself first. The Essential Eight Maturity Verification Tool and the Application Control Verification Tool are available through ASD's Partner Portal. Fixing a failed test before the assessor arrives costs less than a failed finding. The process guide explains how the assessor grades what you provide.
How should exceptions be prepared?
List every control you cannot meet. For each, write the justification, the compensating control, its expected lifetime, who owns the risk, who approved it and when it will be reviewed again. ASD says exceptions should not be approved beyond one year, and that risk acceptance of a whole strategy counts as Maturity Level Zero. The full rules are in exceptions and compensating controls.
Should a first-time organisation use the Essential Eight or ASD Essentials?
ASD says organisations that have not implemented the Essential Eight can implement the Essentials for enterprise IT directly and do not need its transition guidance. But if a contract, regulator or the PSPF asks for an Essential Eight maturity level, that is what an assessor will test, and ASD says to keep meeting current obligations until regulators advise otherwise. Ask the party requiring the assessment which they accept. The transition guide has the dated record.
Which platform helps a lean team with a first assessment?
In the lean team ranking, where expert help carries 35 percent and AI 15 percent, the top three are Vanta at 5.25, 6clicks at 4.55 and Drata at 4.50. Vanta's score rests on APAC-based Customer Success Managers named on its Essential Eight page. 6clicks has a dedicated customer success manager and technical contact in its licence, with no Essential Eight scope stated. Drata describes individualised support options, with no Essential Eight expert stated as included.
Ask each platform what its experts will do on your assessment: scoping, gap analysis and remediation planning, or advice only. The scores record what the pages say, and none of the pages read names an assessor who runs the assessment itself.
Frequently asked questions
Can I jump straight to implementing my target maturity level?
ASD advises implementing and assessing each level progressively, so each is validated before moving on. A staged approach also lets an organisation find unanticipated consequences and give staff time to adjust.
Sources
- ASD, Essential Eight assessment process guide (October 2024), Internet Archive snapshot of cyber.gov.au, read 18 Nov 2026
- ASD, Essential Eight maturity model (November 2023), Internet Archive snapshot of cyber.gov.au, read 18 Nov 2026
- ASD, Essential Eight maturity model FAQ, Internet Archive snapshot of cyber.gov.au, read 18 Nov 2026
- ASD, Transitioning from the Essential Eight, Internet Archive snapshot of cyber.gov.au, read 18 Nov 2026
- Vanta, Essential Eight product page, read 18 Nov 2026
- Drata help centre, example evidence for not monitored controls, Essential Eight, read 18 Nov 2026
Last reviewed 18 Nov 2026