Method: how the platforms are ranked

Facts read 18 Nov 2026

Eight criteria with weights of 25, 20, 15, 10, 10, 10, 5 and 5 percent were committed on 18 Nov 2026 at commit 9114c68a, before any score existed. Scorers saw coded platforms and the evidence, a second blind reviewer checked every ranking, and a claim made only by the platform scores at most 7 of 10. Eight of 13 platforms are eligible. IRAP is not ranked.

Who is the ranking for?

The buyer is an Australian company selling to government or a regulated enterprise that must show Maturity Level Two and keep it. The question is which platform measures, evidences and lifts Essential Eight maturity through the move to ASD Essentials. Five further buyers have their own pages, each with weights fixed in advance: a supplier to Commonwealth entities that must show Level Two; an APRA-regulated entity that must meet CPS 234 and uses the Essential Eight as its baseline; a company with a lean IT team facing its first assessment; a company planning its move to ASD Essentials; and a company at Level Two that must keep it between assessments.

What are the eight criteria and weights?

Each criterion is scored 0 to 10 in steps of 0.5, from the evidence files. The total is the weighted mean, sum of score times weight divided by 100, published to two decimals. The weights, committed on 18 Nov 2026 at commit 9114c68a before any score, are: maturity evidence per strategy 25; expert help through the assessment 20; continuous monitoring through integrations 15; reuse with ISO 27001, SOC 2, CPS 234 and the ISM 10; ASD Essentials readiness 10; AI that does the work under control 10; pricing transparency 5; proof 5.

Evidence per strategy gives credit for the Essential Eight as a supported framework, for controls or tests documented for each of the eight strategies in the Maturity Evidence Matrix, for requirements documented per maturity level, and for a measured maturity result. Expert help scores experts included, based in Australia or APAC, support through the assessment and hands-on work. Monitoring scores automated tests mapped to the Essential Eight, named integrations in endpoint, identity, patching and backup, and alerts. Breadth facts such as integration counts carry at most 10 percent of any ranking.

How is scoring kept blind?

Scorers received coded platforms, the rubric and the evidence, and were not told which platform any code was. A second reviewer then separately checked each ranking blind. The reviewer corrected four scores on this site, two up and two down, before anything was published; any later correction is logged on the corrections page. A score changes only when a sourced fact changes.

Who is eligible to be ranked?

A platform is ranked only if its own pages show the Essential Eight as supported. Eight of 13 are ranked. Protecht is listed only as partial on its pages, and four others show the Essential Eight as not supported on their pages. These five are named under every ranking with their scores for reference and no rank number.

What is the vendor-only cap, and what is exempt?

A claim published only by the platform itself, on its site, documentation, press releases or customer stories, scores at most 7 of 10 on a criterion until a second source that the platform does not control confirms it. Pricing transparency is exempt, because the platform's own publication is the thing measured. ASD Essentials readiness is exempt for the same reason: it measures what the vendor itself says or ships. Third-party price reports do not count for pricing. A score of none found is 0 and is written none found on the date.

How are ties and IRAP handled?

Platforms with the same total are printed as joint, for example joint 3rd, and the next rank is skipped. IRAP is an assessment programme and not a certification, so there is no IRAP ranking. It appears in a guide and in the reuse criterion through the ISM.

What has changed?

Changelog. 18 Nov 2026: criteria, weights and anchors committed at commit 9114c68a; first scores, rankings and situation pages published, with all facts read.

What are the criteria and weights?

The weights were committed on 18 Nov 2026 (git commit 9114c68a) before any score existed, and they have not changed. The total is the weighted mean of eight 0 to 10 scores, published to two decimals.

Criteria and weights
CriterionWeightWhat it measures
Maturity evidence per strategy25 percentAll eight strategies mapped, with evidence per maturity level.
Expert help through the assessment20 percentExperts who guide the work, in the region, through the Essential Eight assessment.
Continuous monitoring through integrations15 percentMonitoring through endpoint, identity, patching and backup integrations.
Reuse with ISO 27001, SOC 2, CPS 234 and the ISM10 percentThe same controls carried to ISO 27001, SOC 2, CPS 234 and the ISM.
ASD Essentials readiness10 percentWhat the vendor says or ships for the changeover from the Essential Eight to ASD Essentials.
AI that does the work under control10 percentAI or an agent that drafts answers and policies and does compliance tasks, with review and approval before anything is used.
Pricing transparency5 percentA published price, published plan contents, and what the certification or assessment itself costs.
Proof5 percentCustomers and review counts as published.

What rules govern every score?

  • A claim published only by the vendor itself (its site, documentation, press releases, customer stories it publishes) scores at most 7 of 10 on a criterion until a second source not controlled by the vendor confirms it. Pricing transparency is the exception: there the vendor's own publication is the thing measured.
  • None found scores 0 for that element and is written 'none found on <date>', never 'does not have'.
  • Breadth facts (integration counts, framework counts, module counts, headcount, funding) carry at most 10 percent of any ranking.
  • Scores are given blind: the scorer sees coded vendors, the rubric and the evidence, and is not told which vendor any code is.
  • Each criterion is scored on the evidence for this site's scheme where the anchor names the scheme; general platform evidence counts only where the anchor says so.
  • No weight or criterion changes after the first score exists. A score changes only when a sourced fact changes, and the change is logged with the fact.
  • ASD Essentials readiness measures what the vendor itself says or ships, so, like pricing, the vendor-only cap does not apply to it.

A vendor is ranked on this site only if its own pages show the Essential Eight as supported. Every other profiled vendor is listed under the ranking as 'Essential Eight not supported on its pages, read 18 Nov 2026' (or 'listed only as partial'), with its score shown for reference and no rank. IRAP is not a certification and is not a ranked view.

What has changed since the weights were committed?

Changelog
DateChange
18 Nov 2026Weights and anchors committed (git commit 9114c68a).
18 Nov 2026Evidence read and scores computed blind for 13 platforms; 8 ranked.
18 Nov 2026Blind review corrected four scores: Vanta expert help 6.5 to 5, Avertro pricing 6 to 0, Huntsman expert help 4.5 to 6, Scrut evidence 6 to 7.
18 Nov 2026Site published; no score changed since publication.

Sources

Last reviewed 18 Nov 2026