How "maturity evidence per strategy" is scored for Essential Eight platforms
Maturity evidence per strategy carries 25 percent of the index and measures all eight strategies mapped, with evidence per maturity level. The highest score is 7 of 10, for Drata; Scytale scores 5 of 10, 6th of 13 platforms on this criterion.
How is this criterion scored?
Add: (a) the Essential Eight supported as a framework in the product 2; (b) per strategy, controls, tests or evidence documented for that strategy: 0.5 for each of the eight strategies marked supported in the Maturity Evidence Matrix, 0.25 for each marked partial, up to 4; (c) maturity levels: requirements or evidence documented per maturity level for ML1 to ML3 3, for ML1 and ML2 only 2, levels named without per-level detail 1; (d) a measured maturity result: the product rates the current maturity level from system data or produces a maturity or gap report 1. Cap 10. Vendor-only evidence caps the total at 7.
Weight in the default index: 25 percent. Situation weights range from 20 to 35 percent.
What does each platform score on it?
| Platform | Score | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Drata | 7 | Essential Eight is a supported framework with a help collection. The matrix marks seven strategies supported and macros partial (3.75). The requirement guide describes ML1, ML2 and ML3, and the framework page tracks gaps by maturity level. The 9.75 total is capped at 7 because no third-party record confirms the Essential Eight work. |
| Scrut Automation | 7 | The framework library lists separate Essential Eight Level 1 and Level 2 frameworks, with no Level 3, so requirements per level for ML1 and ML2 only earns 2. All eight strategies are partial in the matrix (2). The product also produces an automated readiness report showing gaps (1). The total is 7, which is also the vendor-only cap. |
| Vanta | 7 | A dedicated Essential Eight page has pre-mapped templates for all eight strategies. The matrix marks three strategies supported and five partial (2.75). The product page says Maturity Levels 1 to 3, but a blog says the built-in framework is for Maturity Level Two and Level 3 needs custom controls, so the narrower claim is used (2). A maturity rating or gap report: none found on 18 Nov 2026. |
| 6clicks | 6 | A dedicated ASD Essential Eight page offers maturity assessment templates and "6clicks-assisted scoring". All eight strategies are partial in the matrix (2). Levels are stated as "Maturity Level Zero to Three" with no per-strategy level detail (1). Structured maturity assessments give a measured result (1). |
| Huntsman Security | 6 | The Auditor and Scorecard measure the ACSC Essential Eight Maturity Model. All eight strategies are partial in the matrix (2). Levels are named as "Levels 0, 3" per control with no per-level detail (1). The product rates the maturity level from collected system data (1). |
| Avertro | 5 | Essential Eight (AU) is listed as a supported framework. All eight strategies are partial in the matrix because no strategy detail was found (2). Maturity levels: none found on 18 Nov 2026. A maturity assessment against frameworks and board reporting "aligned to NIST and Essential Eight" earn the result point. |
| Scytale | 5 | Essential 8 is on the frameworks list, announced 22 June 2023. All eight strategies are partial in the matrix (2). Maturity Levels 0 to 3 are described only in general in a July 2023 blog (1). A product maturity rating or Essential Eight gap report: none found on 18 Nov 2026. |
| Secureframe | 5 | Essential 8 is on the frameworks page with stated out-of-the-box support. All eight strategies are partial in the matrix (2). The three maturity levels are described in a blog only (1). A product maturity rating or gap report: none found on 18 Nov 2026. |
| Protecht | 3 | Essential Eight is named only as a framework Protecht "can support" for alignment and mapping, with no control library, so it is partial and earns no framework points. All eight strategies are partial in the matrix (2). A blog names Maturity Levels Zero to Three in text (1). A product maturity result: none found on 18 Nov 2026. |
| Comp AI | 0.5 | Essential Eight framework: none found on 18 Nov 2026. Only multi-factor authentication is partial in the matrix, from generic per-user 2FA status in the API (0.25, rounded to 0.5). Maturity levels and a maturity result: none found. |
| Delve | 0 | Essential Eight: none found on 18 Nov 2026 at the home page, sitemap or framework pages. No strategy, maturity level or maturity result evidence was found. |
| Sprinto | 0 | Essential Eight: none found on 18 Nov 2026 at the frameworks page, framework sitemap or docs. No strategy, maturity level or maturity result evidence was found. |
| Thoropass | 0 | Essential Eight: none found on 18 Nov 2026 at the frameworks page, sitemap or product updates. No strategy, maturity level or maturity result evidence was found. |
Sources
- Platform profiles with sources for every score, read 18 Nov 2026
Last reviewed 18 Nov 2026