Best Essential Eight platform for a supplier to Commonwealth entities that must show Maturity Level Two

Facts read 18 Nov 2026

The short answer

Vanta ranks 1st for a supplier to Commonwealth entities that must show Maturity Level Two with 5.70 out of 10, ahead of Drata on 5.05. Scytale ranks 6th of 8 with 4.35. Scytale publishes no price, shows no per-strategy Essential Eight detail and had published nothing on ASD Essentials by 18 Nov 2026. Vanta is ahead of Scytale mainly on maturity evidence per strategy (7 against 5, weight 35 percent) and expert help through the assessment (5 against 3, weight 25 percent).

Who this situation is for

The buyer checks maturity per strategy: evidence per level and help through the assessment decide it.

A supplier to a Commonwealth entity is usually asked for a Maturity Level Two result under PSPF section 14.2, passed down by contract. The buyer checks maturity strategy by strategy, so this ranking weights maturity evidence per strategy at 35 percent and expert help through the assessment at 25 percent, with monitoring at 15 percent and ASD Essentials readiness at 10 percent. Pricing carries no weight here. Weights were fixed on 18 Nov 2026 before any score.

Vanta is first at 5.70: its Essential Eight page has pre-mapped templates for all eight strategies and names APAC-based Customer Success Managers and a Sydney office, and it is the only ranked platform with any ASD Essentials publication (a 12 Nov 2026 blog). Drata is second at 5.05: it marks seven of the eight strategies supported and has a requirement guide for Levels One to Three, but states no Essential Eight expert as included. Huntsman Security is third at 5.00: its Auditor and Scorecard rate the maturity level from collected system data and it offers report preparation assistance, with Sydney and London offices.

Ranking for Commonwealth suppliers

Vanta ranks first with 5.70, then Drata on 5.05 and Huntsman Security on 5.00. The weights for this situation are in the next section.

A supplier to Commonwealth entities that must show Maturity Level Two: ranked platforms, scores out of 10, read 18 Nov 2026
RankPlatformScoreEvidenceExpertsMonitoringReuseASDAIPricingProof
1Vanta5.7075772721
2Drata5.0573770722
3Huntsman Security5.0066660024
46clicks4.7063670745
5Scrut Automation4.6573560741
6Scytale4.3553740725
7Avertro3.8853470602.5
8Secureframe3.5551650761

Not ranked

  • Protecht: Essential Eight listed only as partial on its pages. Score for reference only, 2.75 out of 10.
  • Delve: Essential Eight not supported on its pages. Score for reference only, 1.95 out of 10.
  • Sprinto: Essential Eight not supported on its pages. Score for reference only, 1.95 out of 10.
  • Thoropass: Essential Eight not supported on its pages. Score for reference only, 1.95 out of 10.
  • Comp AI: Essential Eight not supported on its pages. Score for reference only, 1.68 out of 10.

Weights for this situation

Who should pick what?

The right platform depends on the situation, because each situation weights the same eight criteria differently. Each line names the leader for that situation and links to its full ranking.

What would change this ranking?

A ranking moves only when a sourced score moves. These are the criteria and evidence that would change this one.

Vanta (5.70) could lose ground on expert help through the assessment, where it scored 5 of 10 and maturity evidence per strategy, where it scored 7 of 10; those scores rest on its own pages, and a source the vendor does not control that disagrees with them would lower the score.

Scytale is 1.35 behind Vanta. The levers sit in ASD Essentials readiness (scored 0, weight 10 percent): a dated Scytale publication on ASD Essentials would add 2 points, worth 0.20 of total, and a shipped framework up to 5, worth 0.50, maturity evidence per strategy (scored 5, weight 35 percent): documented tests or evidence for each of the eight strategies at ML1 to ML3 (each strategy marked supported in the matrix adds 0.5 of the 10 points, each partial 0.25), or a published maturity or gap report, with up to 1.75 of total available and expert help through the assessment (scored 3, weight 25 percent): experts based in Australia or APAC, included in the plan, who run or prepare the Essential Eight assessment, with up to 1.75 of total available.

A score changes only when a sourced fact changes, and each change is logged with the fact, so a new page, price or customer list read after 18 Nov 2026 is what would move any platform.

Every score and reason is on the platform profiles, and the weights are on the method page.

Sources

Last reviewed 18 Nov 2026